Then Jesus said to him, “Put your sword back into its place. For all who take the sword will perish by the sword.
Peter's blow in the garden was brave, loyal, and completely wrong. His answer disarms His own disciple, and it sets a rule for anyone who picks up the world's weapons for God's cause.
A loyal blow that misjudged the Master
One writer notes that Peter's zeal made his Master look small.
Numerical Bible NotesThe Lord had told any disciple who had no sword to sell even his coat and buy one (Luke 22:36). Peter probably took this literally. The moment he sees his beloved Master attacked, his weapon is out, and he strikes a servant of the high priest and cuts off his ear. But he has belittled and misrepresented the One he wanted to serve. His Master must have fallen very low indeed, if He needed His disciple's sword to get Him out of hands like these. If He yields, it is to God, not to man.
The weapon clashed with the Man beside it.
C. H. MackintoshA sword was out of keeping, totally out of place, in the company of the meek and lowly Sufferer! … Peter was completely outside the current of his Master's spirit. He had not one thought in common with Him about His path of suffering. He wanted to defend Him with weapons of the flesh, forgetting that His kingdom was not of this world.
The command and the warning
Matthew records the order and the reason, but not the healing of the ear that Luke gives.
Leslie M. GrantBut this did not turn into a fight. The Lord Jesus was in perfect control of the situation. He gives the royal command to put the sword away, and adds that by taking the sword a man exposes himself to perishing with the sword. Matthew does not mention His faithful mercy in restoring the ear. Matthew stresses His authority more, rather than His grace as Luke does.
The Lord's words reach past that one night.
J. N. DarbyThe character of the patience and the faith of the saints is not to resist at all. This is true at all times. If anyone uses the weapons of the flesh, those weapons will master him. Whoever draws the sword shall perish by the sword.
Why He refused rescue
The Lord was not helpless that night. Scripture, not weakness, kept Him there.
J. N. DarbyHe could have had twelve legions of angels. But then how would the Scriptures come true, which said it must be so? … He was going as a lamb to the slaughter. This was His place. He was always perfectly obedient, and He was learning obedience by the things He suffered. That path is ours. If a Christian uses human violence and human weapons, the world will meet him with human weapons that are stronger.
A permanent change, not a passing rebuke
Commentators see this word as settling how the kingdom now advances.
C E StuartPeter did use the sword to defend his Master. Matthew records the Lord's reproof (26:52), and it fits his Gospel, since it marked a change in the way opponents were to be dealt with. That reproof settled for ever the idea of spreading the kingdom of God now by such weapons. "All who take the sword will perish by the sword." And in a future time this same principle will hold good (Rev. 13:10).
One writer narrows down who the Lord was speaking to.
J. T. MawsonThe Lord did not say this to the world in general, and He did not mean nations quarrelling with one another. He aimed it at the thought in the hearts of His disciples that the sword would set up His kingdom. Others of the Lord's people have had the same thought since that memorable night, and have perished by the sword as the Lord said they would.
The sword that God still authorises
Taking the sword from the disciple is not the same as taking it from the magistrate.
Morrish Bible DictionaryScripture keeps referring to the sword as the instrument of death. The New Testament speaks of the magistrate carrying it (Rom. 13:4). This shows that the gospel does not set aside God's governmental principle of capital punishment, which God commanded after the flood (Gen. 9:5-6).
Summary
- Sword drawn — Peter's blow came from real love. But it treated the Lord as someone who needed a fisherman's blade to save Him.
- Sword sheathed — the command is a royal one. Matthew shows His authority over the scene, not the mercy that healed the ear.
- Sword returns — the warning holds at all times. Whoever takes up the weapons of the flesh falls under them.
- Sword refused — He could have called angels. But Scripture had marked out the path, and He took the place of the obedient Lamb.
- Sword relocated — God still puts a sword in the magistrate's hand to punish evil. What He removed was the sword as a way to advance His kingdom.