And the King will answer them, ‘Truly, I say to you, as you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.’
The King has taken His throne, the nations stand before Him, and He has just given His verdict — now He gives His reason. It is startling: He counts kindness shown to poor, suffering people as kindness done to Himself — so who are these "brothers" whose treatment decides everything?
Not the last judgment
One writer says the common reading of this scene gets it wrong. The sorting of sheep and goats belongs to the living, not the dead:
The Bible TreasuryIt is commonly supposed that the judgment spoken of in this chapter is the last judgment — the general judgment. This is a mistake. It is the judgment of the nations living on the earth, and not of the dead. There is no question of resurrection here. It is the judgment of the nations… People think it is the judgment of the dead because of this sentence: "And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life." But that only means the judgment of the living will be final, just as the judgment of the dead is final.
Three parties, not two
Many assume the sheep are all the saved and the goats all the lost. But the verse names a third group:
C. H. MackintoshAlmost everyone in the Christian world believes that "the sheep" stand for all God's people, from the beginning of time to the end. They believe "the goats" stand for all the wicked, from first to last. But if that is so, what are we to make of the third party referred to here, under the title of "these My brethren"? The King addresses both the sheep and the goats about this third class. Indeed, the very ground of judgment is the treatment of the King's brethren. It would be an obvious absurdity to say the sheep were themselves the people referred to. If that were so, the wording would be quite different. Instead of "as you did it to one of the least of these My brothers," we would hear the King say, "as you did it to one another."
Who the "brethren" are
Darby identifies the brothers as Jewish messengers who will carry the message of the coming kingdom to the nations.
J. N. DarbyThe "brethren," I have no doubt, will be the remnant who will have preached the gospel of the kingdom among the Gentiles. The welcome given to those messengers decides the outcome for those who now appear in judgment. Just as surely, I believe they are Jews who will carry this testimony, and whom Jesus calls His brethren at that time.
Why a meal counts as evidence
A meal sounds too small to settle anyone's eternity. But see what it cost the giver, and what it showed:
William KellyThe pressure against His messengers will be enormous. If any receive them well, it will be from faith. I grant that the measure of their faith is small. They do not yet know that honouring His brothers is honouring Him.
This is why an open judgment can proceed on deeds without making deeds the source of blessing:
F. B. HoleThe true state of every heart is known to God quite apart from works. Yet public judgment always goes by works. Works show exactly what that state is. So everyone can see that God judges rightly… Those who had faith declared it by their works. Those who had no faith equally declared it by their works.
The surprise of the righteous
The sheep are surprised by the King's praise. They do not remember feeding Him:
William KellyThey were, up to that moment, ignorant that in showing acts of love and kindness toward Christ's messengers, so much was done toward Christ Himself. Their last lesson was the first one Paul learned on the road to Damascus. The words that shook him were these: "I am Jesus, whom you are persecuting." The Lord taught Paul that to persecute His people on earth is to persecute Christ in heaven. They and Christ are one.
The principle that reaches us
The scene is still future, but the truth behind it works now:
F. B. HoleThose who would strike a blow at Christ today strike at His saints. Those who would serve Christ today care for and serve His saints. What is done to even the least of His brethren, He will accept as done to Himself… Real devotion to Christ shows itself in service to His cause and His people, far more than in warm words.
And nothing is too small to be filed away:
The Bible TreasuryWe know this verse applies to others, not to us, but the principle still holds for everyone. The act here is done in secret. Where the heart is moved by love for Christ to show even the smallest kindness, the Lord will not forget it.
Summary
- Throne — Here the King judges the living nations, not the dead. The outcome is eternal, and that is what makes it final.
- Three — Sheep, goats, and "My brothers" are three separate groups. How people treat the brothers decides the other two.
- Test — Food, water, shelter, clothing, and prison visits came under heavy pressure. They were not simple charity. They were faith at work when turning away would have been safer.
- Me — The King takes every act as done to Himself. That is the truth that stopped Paul on the road: to touch His people is to touch Him.
- Memory — The righteous had forgotten what they did; He had not. The smallest kindness done for love of Christ is never lost.