Luke 21:7

And they asked him, “Teacher, when will these things be, and what will be the sign when these things are about to take place?”
Luke 21:7 · ESVView all translations

The disciples have been admiring the temple's fine stonework. The Lord has just told them that not one stone will remain on another. So they ask: when, and by what sign? The three Gospel writers each report that question differently, and the difference shapes everything that follows.

Admiration for a Condemned House

One commentator ties their admiration for the stones to a deeper blindness:

The natural, earthbound thoughts of men then come out in another direction. Some drew attention to the decorations of the temple with its attractive and expensive stones and ornaments. How little man sees as God does! The temple was God's house, but men gave more honour to the house than to its Lord: in fact it had become virtually their house. The Lord pronounced solemn judgment upon it: there would not be left one stone upon another.

Leslie M. Grant

Two Questions, Not One

In Matthew the same question follows a different conversation:

In Matthew, Jesus had just spoken of the Jews' house being left desolate. He had also spoken of His own departure, until they should receive Him as the one coming "in the name of the Lord." Then someone points Him to the temple, and He foretells its ruin. So the disciples ask, "When will these things be? And what will be the sign of your coming and of the end of the age?" Here the leading thought is the "end of the age," and the Lord's reappearance after His predicted withdrawal. In Luke, however, Jesus has not been speaking of His departure or return, but simply foretelling the overthrow of the temple.

T. B. Baines

This does not mean one writer got it wrong:

All three tell us He was asked about the desolation of the temple. But Matthew and Mark add questions about what is still future, while Luke keeps to questions about what is now past. Luke tells us the questions were about the beginning of Jerusalem's troubles, not the end of them. There is no real difficulty here. All these questions were doubtless put to Him. But each writer records the ones that match the Lord's reply, as the Spirit guided him.

C. E. Stuart

What Luke Alone Preserves

Because Luke keeps the narrower question, he keeps a body of detail no other Gospel gives:

Notice that the Holy Spirit inspired the writer to drop the question about the coming of the Son of man and the completion of the age. As with Mark, they ask when the destruction of the temple will be, and the sign of its beginning. The Lord fully replies, but as usual gives much more... On the other hand, only here do we get clear light on the coming siege and capture of Jerusalem by the Romans. Only here do we read of its later shameful subjection, until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled.

William Kelly

Where the Answer Lands

The Lord gives the sign thirteen verses later:

In verse 20 He says: "But when you see Jerusalem surrounded by armies, then know that its desolation has come near." Here is the plain reply to the only part of the disciples' question which Luke records. Armies surrounding Jerusalem would be the sign that its desolation was near.

W. Trotter

A Warning Instead of a Date

Their request for a date exposes a common blind spot:

This coming destruction shows that Christ had not come to establish His kingdom. Yet they asked Him when these things would take place. People usually want to know the order of events. They are not concerned about the moral issues behind those events. They asked for a sign, little realising that present moral and spiritual conditions matter most in God's future judgments.

Leslie M. Grant

He warns them about a promise of rest that comes too early:

"Watch out," He says, "people will be promising you rest before rest comes." ... The Lord here anticipates the very same thing. He says, "Now, do not mistake. The time cannot draw near until there has been judgment." And that is what I am bold to say to the world now. You are not going to have a kingdom — the time of glory is not drawing near; nor will it, until judgment has purged the earth.

J. G. Bellett

Summary

- Stones — The disciples honoured the building above its Lord. That misplaced admiration drew out the whole prophecy.

- Question — Luke records only the narrow half of what was asked: when the temple falls, and by what sign. Matthew adds the question about His coming and the end of the age.

- Selection — All the questions were really asked. Each writer keeps the ones that match the answer he records.

- Sign — Luke's answer arrives at verse 20: armies encircling Jerusalem, and after that the city's long subjection until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled.

- Warning — Before any date, the Lord says: do not be fooled. Wanting a timetable is not being ready. Glory never comes before judgment.

Reviewed by Orion on August 23, 2026
Luke 21:7 Commentary | True Bible Answers