And he placed the breastpiece on him, and in the breastpiece he put the Urim and the Thummim.
Moses is dressing Aaron as high priest, and here he fastens the breastplate on him and puts the Urim and the Thummim inside. What were these objects, and why is a piece that carries the names of God's people called a breastplate of judgment?
Dressed for Glory, Not for Atonement
Moses dressed Aaron; the priest put on nothing himself. These robes were not the plain linen of the Day of Atonement:
William KellyThe garments — the coat, the robe and ephod, the breastplate with the Urim and the Thummim, and the turban with the golden plate — were not those of the atonement day, of linen only, but "for glory and beauty." They express what Christ is and does for us as the great High Priest before God... The breastplate of judgment was on his heart for a memorial continually. It held a still more precious token: twelve stones of rare value, each bearing a name of Israel's sons. In it Moses put the Urim and the Thummim, the lights and the perfections.
Something Placed Inside
The wording matters. Moses does not engrave the Urim and Thummim. He puts them into a breastplate — the ESV calls it the breastpiece — that already held its twelve stones:
Morrish Bible DictionaryThe meaning of these Hebrew words is "lights" and "perfections." They were distinct from the gems on the breastplate, for Moses put the breastplate on Aaron, and "in the breastpiece he put the Urim and the Thummim" (Lev. 8:8). It is clear that God answered questions by means of the Urim and the Thummim.
Scripture never says what they looked like or how they worked. One writer warns against filling that silence:
A. J. PollockFor some wise reason Scripture does not give the details of how they were placed in the breastplate, or how they worked. Guessing about this would serve no good purpose. Moses put them in "the breastplate of judgment." The breastplate seems to get this title from the Urim and Thummim. Judgment here does not mean condemnation, but discernment and guidance. In everyday speech we speak of a man of sound judgment, that is, one able to give wise counsel.
Traffic in Both Directions
The breastplate carried Israel's names up to God. The Urim brought God's answers back down:
C. H. MackintoshMany passages of the Word connect the "Urim" with God making His mind known on the questions that came up in Israel's history. For example, at the appointment of Joshua we read, "He shall stand before Eleazar the priest, who shall inquire for him by the judgment of the Urim before the Lord" (Num. 27:21)... "And when Saul inquired of the Lord, the Lord did not answer him, either by dreams, or by Urim, or by prophets" (1 Sam. 28:6)... So we learn two things. The high priest carried the judgment of the congregation before the Lord. He also brought the judgment of the Lord back to the congregation.
Names Seen in the Light
Why "judgment" and not "love"? One writer answers that question:
The Christian's FriendThe breastplate is called the breastplate of judgment. We might have thought it would be called the breastplate of love. But love is made perfect with us in just this, that we might have confidence for the day of judgment, because as He is, so also are we in this world. What can the holy judgment of God say to those who are only seen as written in each precious stone? ... They shone in the breastplate, and made clear the beauty and perfection of the setting of the names according to the judgment of God.
A gem is made for light. That is why jewels carry the names:
C. H. MackintoshA precious stone has this special excellence: the stronger the light shone on it, the brighter it shines... Whatever their weaknesses, errors, or failures, their names sparkled on the breastplate and never lost their brilliance. The Lord had set them there, and who could pluck them from it?
The Priest Who Stands Up
Some questions in Israel had to wait for a priest who could give God's answer:
An Outline of Sound WordsIn Nehemiah's day there were matters that could not be settled until a priest stood up with Urim and Thummim. In the Lord Jesus we have such a Priest, One in whom is all the mind of God, in whom all light and perfections are found.
It also shapes how believers settle hard cases among themselves:
L. M. GrantWe too need to truly recognise the lights and perfections of Christ in His saints. Without that, we will not have the discernment to judge any important problem that arises.
Summary
- Placed, not earned. Moses put the breastplate on Aaron and set the Urim and Thummim inside. The priest received his standing from another's hand.
- Lights and perfections. That is what the two Hebrew words mean. Scripture never says how they looked or worked, and writers refuse to guess.
- Judgment, not condemnation. Here judgment means discernment and guidance, like a person of sound judgment who gives wise counsel.
- Both directions. The names went up to God on the priest's heart; God's answers came back down through the same breastplate.
- The Priest who stands up. Some matters had to wait for a priest with Urim and Thummim. Commentators find that Priest in Christ, in whom all light and perfections are found.