In those days there was no king in Israel. Everyone did what was right in his own eyes.
Israel had no earthly king in those days. The book ends by naming what filled that empty space: each person's own judgment of what was right. This closing line is not a stray comment on politics. It is the verdict on everything the book has just described, and it asks who should have been ruling all along.
Two Causes
The verse names two things, and one produces the other. Moses had warned of this long before Israel entered the land:
Hamilton SmithMoses instructed the people about how they were to live once they had taken possession of the land. He said plainly, "You shall not do according to all that we are doing here today, everyone doing whatever is right in his own eyes" (Deut. 12:8). Three hundred years after this warning we find the people in the land. But the closing chapters of Judges record them in a low moral condition, marked by gross corruption and violence. Two causes lie behind that low condition. First, they had thrown off the authority of God as their King; secondly, as a result, every man was doing what was right in his own eyes.
The Missing King
The words "no king in Israel" do not mean the throne was empty. They mean Israel refused a King:
H. L. RossierThe time had not yet come when Israel would say, "appoint for us a king to judge us like all the nations" (1 Sam. 8:5). Until then the people had the LORD as their king. Now God was forgotten or set aside, though Israel had not yet set up a kingship like that of the nations. The people had abandoned God's system of government, and they had not yet declared the world's system either.
Right In His Own Eyes
"Right in his own eyes" sounds sincere. That is what makes it dangerous:
H. L. RossierThey had, as in the present day, the reign of liberty of conscience. Each claimed to have the "light of his conscience" for guidance, while they set aside the true light of the word of God and no longer turned to it... Conscience, despite its immense value for man, is not a guide but a judge — a wholly different thing. Man does not listen to this judge, yet pretends to honour it by making it his guide. But how can it lead him, when it may fall asleep, grow hard, or even lose all feeling?... They followed the impulses of their own hearts, as long as they thought they were doing right. This plunged them into frightful wickedness.
The Nation's Report Card
This is the last word on a people God redeemed for a purpose:
William KellyThey forsook the LORD, the God of their fathers, and served the gods of the surrounding nations. They ignored the code of righteous laws Moses gave them for an orderly national life that God could accept. Lawlessness prevailed throughout the twelve tribes. In short, the final sentence of this book sums up the moral condition of Israel — a people redeemed to be a model of righteous government in the eyes of all other nations.
What God Does With It
God does not pretend the situation is better than it is. But He does not leave His own in it:
H. L. RossierGod did not change that deplorable state of things; He simply states the fact. But He led His own away from the confused light of conscience, which judged them yet never guided them. He brought them back to the pure light of His own infallible word. That word was able to lead them, to build them up, and to give them "the inheritance among all those who are sanctified" (compare Acts 20:32).
The Longing In The Line
Read one way, the line is despair. Read another, it is a longing pointing forward to a King:
Samuel RidoutWhat a world of longing there is in that expression, "there was no king in Israel." How it tells of the only hope there could be for God's people. It was to have His King. God Himself surely wanted to be their king, would have been their king, but they refused Him... At last God gives them, as a picture, the man after His own heart. David in that way surely points to the coming King for Israel — the King the nation still waits for, though it does not know it.
The very next book in the Bible answers with quiet, ordinary faith:
A. J. PollockIs God defeated? No — Ruth follows Judges. There we find humble and obscure people in whose hearts God has worked, and who are altogether delightful in their setting. We get Naomi, Ruth, Boaz, and the line set for David — and in truth for David's greater Son, the Lord from heaven.
The Same Principle Today
The pattern did not stay in the ancient world:
C. StanleyThese words also describe the whole history of the Christian world. Perhaps the cause of every evil division is just that — the failure to truly acknowledge the Lordship and authority of Christ, in the fear of the Lord. Where that is missing, every man is sure to do what is right in his own eyes — his own will.
Summary
- No king — the throne was not empty by accident; God Himself wanted to be their king, but they refused Him.
- No guide — they made conscience their guide when it is only a judge, and set the word of God aside.
- No limit — sincerity became the excuse. People followed their own hearts, sure they were right, and fell into terrible things.
- No pretence — God does not tidy the record; He states the ruin plainly and calls His own back to His word.
- No despair — the missing king is the ache the whole book leaves behind, and Ruth at once begins to trace the line to the King who was coming.