Go and cry out to the gods whom you have chosen; let them save you in the time of your distress.”
Crushed by years of oppression, Israel has just confessed that they left God for idols. God's reply is not rescue: He sends them back to the gods they chose.
God takes them at their word
God is not slamming the door. He speaks in irony. He lets Israel hear their own choice read back to them, and shows the gap between confessing sin and undoing it.
Samuel RidoutThere is confession, but God is faithful. He must show them that getting away from Him is one thing, and getting back is quite another. It is one thing to have left Him and to confess the power of the enemy. But mere confession is not going to undo my departure from God. After a long course of discipline God may bring me back to a sense of my sin. I may turn and confess it to Him with all my heart. Does that mean that I am going to regain all that I have lost at once? Ah no! We have to drink the water with the ground-up golden calf scattered on its surface. We have to reap what we have sown, and that is what Israel found, and it was pressed upon them. In solemn irony, God says, "Go and cry out to the gods whom you have chosen; let them save you in the time of your distress."
Why God lists the rescues first
First God lists rescue after rescue: Egypt, the Amorites, Ammon, the Philistines and more. The list makes Israel weigh how great their sin was.
Leslie M. GrantThe Lord did not deliver them at once. He answered them severely. He reminded them that He had already delivered them from the Egyptians, the Amorites, the people of Ammon and the Philistines. The Sidonians, the Amalekites and Maonites had also oppressed them, and God had delivered Israel from them. Why should He deliver them any more if they give themselves up to false gods? Let them pray to the idols they have chosen. So God makes them think over how great their sin was in leaving Him.
A challenge the idols cannot meet
"Let them save you" is a dare. God gave the same dare to Judah when trouble drove them to pray.
William KellyIn their trouble they might turn to God and say, "Arise and save us." But God challenges their gods to arise, if they can save them. They did not lack numbers — Judah had as many gods as it had cities.
How Israel answered
The idols they chose had no help to give in trouble. Israel stopped bargaining and handed themselves to God on any terms.
Leslie M. GrantWhat could Israel do? They knew their idols had no ability to help them. They could only confess their sin to God again. They showed themselves willing to accept any consequences God, as their ruler, might send. They only plead with Him to deliver them. At the same time they put away their foreign gods, and took the place of serving the Lord.
That order — idols out first, then service — is the hard part of every such turning.
H. Forbes WitherbyYet they said not one word about the foreign gods they had been told to put away. It is always easier to say "We will serve the Lord" than to clear ourselves of idols. It is easier to decide to serve the Lord than to bury our household gods under some oak of Shechem. But God tells us first to bury our idols, and then serve Him. That is the order of what He asks of us, as He says, "cease to do evil, learn to do good."
The refusal was not the end
God's severity here is real, and it is also temporary. The refusal did its work, and then His heart moved.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinBut they kept on pleading and confessing. They put away the foreign gods. They began to serve Him again. He had denied their first cry, yet His soul was grieved for the misery of Israel. What a compassionate Lord He is!
Summary
- Chosen. God's answer names the root: Israel picked these gods. He hands them the results of their own choice.
- Challenged. "Let them save you" is a dare no idol can take up. Judah had as many gods as cities, and not one could stand up to save.
- Costly. Confession is real, but it does not restore at once what leaving God cost. There is still a harvest to reap from what was sown.
- Cleared. Israel's turning became real when the foreign gods went out and service began. Bury the idols first, then promise to serve.
- Compassion. Though God denied their first cry, their misery moved Him. The refusal was His method, not His verdict.