1 Chronicles 1:28

The sons of Abraham: Isaac and Ishmael.
1 Chronicles 1:28 · ESVView all translations

One short line names both of Abraham's sons: the son God promised and the son born first. The order of the two names, and the order of the families listed after them, is where commentators find the meaning.

The Order of the Two Names

The verse names Isaac before Ishmael. Yet the verses that follow trace Ishmael's family first. One writer sees the same order earlier in the chapter, with Shem:

In God's eyes Shem, chosen by grace, has the first place. But in the natural order what is spiritual does not come first, as we have already pointed out. It is the same with Abraham's offspring: "The sons of Abraham: Isaac and Ishmael" (v. 28). Isaac is named first, seen as first in God's thoughts. But Ishmael, the elder, comes first in the list (v. 29) as the seed according to the flesh.

H. L. Rossier

A Rule Running Through the Whole Section

The same pattern shapes the whole opening section of the book:

In the nine chapters that make up this opening section we have the principle that the apostle Paul stated long afterwards: not first the spiritual but the natural, then the spiritual. Even the general genealogy of 1 Chronicles 1 follows this divine purpose.

William Kelly

Why the Natural Comes First

There is a reason for the delay. God does not unfold grace until the other line has been tried and has failed:

God has ordained it so. The whole question of man's responsibility had to be settled before the Man of God's purposes of grace would appear. In fact, grace could not be unfolded until it was first made clear how deep man had fallen when left to himself. This great truth is the foundation of all Scripture. All Scripture presents man's ruin, which nothing can repair, as the basis of the gospel of grace.

H. L. Rossier

Promise, Not Descent

Both men were Abraham's sons. Yet God's choice, not birth order, settled which son carried the promise:

The apostle quotes the saying recorded in Genesis 21:12: "Through Isaac shall your offspring be named." His inspired comment on this is: "it is not the children of the flesh who are the children of God, but the children of the promise are counted as offspring." The flesh can produce nothing except what is flesh… God knew it was a corrupt source, and so a source of nothing but corruption. That is why He passed by Ishmael, the child of the flesh. His election rested on Isaac, the child of promise, the son whose origin lay in the resurrection power of God, shown in His promise years before.

F. B. Hole

(The older translation Hole used reads, "In Isaac shall thy seed be called.")

Isaac Born, Not Ishmael Improved

Ishmael went on to a large future. His standing never changed:

It was not Ishmael changed, but it was Isaac born. The son of the slave woman could never be anything else. He might become a great nation. He might live in the wilderness and become an archer. He might become the father of twelve princes. But he was the son of the slave woman all the while. On the other hand, no matter how weak and despised Isaac might be, he was the son of the free woman. His position and character, his standing and prospects, were all from the Lord.

C. H. Mackintosh

The Rest of Abraham's Family

Abraham had sons by Keturah as well. Where the chapter puts them carries the same message:

In verse 32 the sons of Keturah, Abraham's concubine, are listed as we find them in Genesis 25:1-4. In our chapter they come after Ishmael's descendants (vv. 28-31), to show that they too belong to the line according to the flesh.

H. L. Rossier

Why Such Lists Are Scripture

Readers often skip these chapters as bare names. One commentator answers the objection head-on:

But someone may still challenge us like this: "Do you believe that the long string of names in the opening chapters of 1 Chronicles — those lists of family lines — were inspired by God? Were they written for our learning? And if so, what are we to learn from them?" We say without hesitation that we believe, with reverence, that God inspired all of these. And we have no doubt that their value, interest and importance will be proved in full later on, in the history of the people they especially apply to.

As to what we are to learn from those records of family lines, we believe they teach us a most precious lesson about the Lord's faithful care of His people Israel, and His loving interest in them and in all that concerns them. He watches over them from generation to generation, even though they are scattered and lost to human sight. He knows all about the twelve tribes. He will bring them into view in due time, and plant them in the land of Canaan, the inheritance meant for them, according to His promise to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.

C. H. Mackintosh

Summary

- Order. Isaac stands first in the verse because he is first in God's thoughts. Ishmael's family is traced first because the natural comes before the spiritual.

- Reason. God lets the natural line run its course. Man's ruin must be shown in full before He unfolds grace.

- Choice. Both are Abraham's sons, but only the child of promise is counted as the offspring — descent settles nothing.

- Nature. Isaac's birth did not improve Ishmael. It brought in something new that came wholly from the Lord.

- Care. Ishmael's sons and Keturah's sons close off the line of flesh; the lists that remain show the Lord's faithful watch over His people, generation after generation.

Reviewed by Orion on August 27, 2026