The elder to the beloved Gaius, whom I love in truth.
Commentary for this Verse
This letter opens with no title of office and no church address. It is one older man writing to one friend he calls beloved. Two questions follow: why does John call himself only "the elder," and what does it mean to love someone "in truth"?
"The Elder" — a Title Laid Down
John had every right to open with apostolic authority. Instead he takes the lower place, and commentators see this as deliberate.
William Kelly"The elder," says the apostle. So he steps down from the first place in the church of God, which he had every right to fill. But love takes the better way, and here the Holy Spirit inspired it for the special need... We need not doubt that there was a wise and worthy reason why the apostle John introduced himself as "elder" rather than as apostle, both to the elect lady and to the beloved Gaius.
The word points to age and relationship, not to a post:
Eugene P. Vedder Jr.John writes to those he stood among as an older man. He does not speak of his apostolic authority here. He wrote the letters as "the elder."
Who Gaius Was
Several men named Gaius appear in the New Testament. One writer is careful not to claim more than can be known:
Truth & TestimonyGaius was one of the more common names in the Roman world of the first century. So it is best not to rush to identify the man this letter was sent to with the men of the same name in Acts 19:29, Acts 20:4 or 1 Corinthians 1:14. Paul describes the Gaius of Romans 16:23 as his host. John's well-loved friend certainly knew the privilege of showing Christian hospitality.
The letter says nothing about his gifts. It says a great deal about his character:
Hamilton SmithThere is nothing to show that Gaius was gifted as a teacher or preacher. But he had those spiritual qualities, and without them gift counts for nothing... He comes before us as a humble, gracious and devoted believer. He loved the truth and walked in the truth. He acted in faithfulness and love, helped fellow believers on their journeys, welcomed them into the churches, and so helped to spread the truth. No wonder the Apostle calls him "the beloved Gaius". There was everything in Gaius to draw out the affection of God's people. Who would not want to be a Gaius?
Loved "In Truth"
John valued the generosity of Gaius. But that is not where he rests his love:
William KellyWhether it was the elect lady and her children, or the well-loved Gaius, it is all the same. It was not because of his hospitality, but "whom I love in the truth." No doubt the apostle valued his generosity and care very much. But even in matters completely different from those of his second letter, the mark that pressed on his soul was this: "whom I love in the truth."
One writer sees this as John's constant habit, and gives the reason for it:
J. N. DarbyIt is striking that John, while he speaks of love, always guards it in the clearest way by what he calls "the truth." Real love is in God Himself. He is love, and wherever love is real, the truth as it is in Jesus must guard it, or it is not from God.
Written to a Person, Not a Church
John writes to one man rather than to a church. The reason lies in what had happened where Gaius lived. A man named Diotrephes had taken the first place:
The Christian's FriendIt is only here that the word "Church" appears in John's writings... But now he finds he can trust the Church no longer, and he finds relief in the personal grace of this "beloved Gaius." He had honoured the Church from a distance, but he was disappointed. "Diotrephes, who likes to put himself first," had got in, and John has to fall back on what can never fail: on "truth and love" in the "beloved Gaius."
The Balance With the Second Letter
John's second letter warned the elect lady about dangerous men. This letter adds the other side:
William KellyIf we had only the Second letter, we might be in danger of becoming rigid, hard and suspicious. But the Third letter tells us whom we are to receive, and to receive with all our heart. If dangerous men go about trying to get in, we must not forget true men who are eager to spread the truth of Christ.
Summary
- Elder — John lays down the apostle's title and writes as an older man. Love takes the lower place.
- Beloved — Gaius earns no title either; he is loved not for his gifts or his generosity but "in truth."
- Guarded — the truth always guards real love. Where the two part, it is not from God.
- Personal — when the church failed under Diotrephes, John fell back on the truth and love he found in one man.
- Open-hearted — the second letter warns whom to refuse; this one says whom to receive with all your heart. Both keep a Christian from being hard or careless.